Friday, December 27, 2024

Poor Things (2023)

Watching Poor Things felt like watching a very good Terry Gilliam movie.  There's an interesting alternate-Victorian world, interesting camera shots, and good actors playing unusual characters in the style of a James Whale production.  

There are numerous sex scenes in the middle act that started to feel gratuitous.

The initial direction of the story is good: "what if a person tried to live according to experimentation and scientific thought?"  Though really not simply a person, because while Bella is our protagonist, Godwin models this behavior for her, as does Max (though Max is positioned as more of a partner than teacher).

Unfortunately I think the film sabotages its story in the final minutes.



<spoilers>



Bella's character at her core is non-violent, against doing permanent harm to others, and looking to improve herself and the world around her.  That is, right up until she replaces Victoria Blessington's husband's brain with that of a goat (or sheep), and the final scene has her sipping gin in her father's garden.  I was shocked that she hadn't put Godwin's brain into Alfie's body!  Godwin had a tortured childhood and lived in a body marked by scars that people stared at; if Bella put his brain into Alfie's body, she could allow him to go on his own adventure of discovery, closing the circle of the story that began with Godwin letting Bella go.  As is, Alfie's fate is purely retribution.


3 comments:

  1. We re-watched 12 Monkeys last night because just a few days prior, we watched Le Jetee (if you have never seen La Jetee, I can't recommend it highly enough -- it's not even 30 minutes long and worth every second). I've seen three Gilliams: this one, Brazil, and The Adventures of Baron Munchausen. Is it safe to say that he doesn't exactly make happy movies? I think the last is perhaps the "happiest" -- doesn't make me love them all any less. Definitely Gilliam influences in Yorgos Lanthimos' camerawork for sure.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Ooh, you haven't seen Time Bandits? I'm not entirely sure I can recommend it; it was just part of the 80's cinematic landscape. 12 Monkeys is probably my favorite non-Python Gilliam-directed movie; he co-directed Holy Grail with Terry Jones and did not write the script for 12 Monkeys.

    ReplyDelete
  3. The cast of Time Bandits is unimpeachable...I am intrigued! If I do end up seeing it, I'll report back. 😁

    ReplyDelete